St. Vincent doesn't have an album called ARTPOP (Lady Gaga does, strangely), but she might as well have. The six capital letters perfectly describe what St. Vincent does for a living. She channels current pop culture, twists it through her own musical, historical, poetic, personal lens, and can as one of very few high-profile female musicians present an entirely uncompromising piece of modern art. Her latest album, MASSEDUCTION, is far and away her most POP and least ART album yet, but that's not a bad thing. It's an album that feels urgent, important, and fun at the same time. Global and intimately personal at the same time, like only the greatest ones do.
I've seen St. Vincent live twice. The first time was when she warmed up for Grizzly Bear in Oslo in 2009. She was alone on stage with a Bernhoft-like setup: a couple guitars and a looper pedal. I hadn't heard of her before, but this would have been just after the release of her second album, Actor, the last before she officially became the most hyped indie artist in the world, and certainly the last tour where she was just the opening act. I was impresed and charmed, but not blown away, and the Grizzly Bear show is certainly what sticks today.
The second time was in November last year. It was my last night in St. Louis, and my flatmate James came with me to the show. I still have confused sentiments about the show: Annie Clark was all alone on stage, wielding just her guitar, supported just by unseen instrumentals playing like karaoke tracks, for two hours. She stood in front of four curtains in various locations onstage, and I kept expecting some grand theatrical reveal, but it never came. The first half of the show was old (pre-MASSEDUCTION) material, and the second half was MASSEDUCTION played in full, from start to finish. During this section she was backed by some roof-height visuals playing behind her, showing grotesque, voyeuristic video clips such as ultra close-up, ultra slow-motion loops of Annie eating a slice of cake. Again, mixed emotions. But I think the most suprising aspect of it all was just how bare and stripped-down it was. MASSEDUCTION sounds rich and maximalistic, the kind of album that could have been performed with a full band and a crew of backing dancers. Instead it's just the instrumentals just as on the album; only St. Vincent's live vocal and guitar improvizations jacked up in the mix. I think the result can best be described as a very modernist, slightly absurd, quite provocative and immensely successful critique of pop culture.
The album opens with "Hang on me", whose deliberate restraint and touching intimacy immediately grabs my attention. It lures me in to St. Vincent's world and prepares me for whatever may come next, like the openers on the best albums from Perfume Genius ("I decline", "Otherside") or Susanne Sundfør ("Darlings", "Mantra"). And in all these cases, the tension built from the subtle opener makes the thrill of the banging second track ever so much stronger. "Pills" is an awesome pop song, not stopping after the infectious first three minutes, but morphing over to an epic, Pink Floyd-alluding coda.
The streak continuous for three more very uptempo tracks cementing the album's aesthetic, all a perfect blend of sexy pop hooks and futuristic rock with lots of angry guitar work, gender-bending lyrics and some really awesome transitions. Then comes the quiet piano ballad "Happy birthday, Johnny", which again beckons us to come and sit extra close while Annie sings to whomever ("Johnny's just Johnny. Doesn't everyone know a Johnny?"). It's the third in a 'trilogy' of St. Vincent songs referencing Johnny, the previous of which was the stunning "Prince Johnny" off her self-titled album. It reaches an emotional climax when Johnny sings her own name back at her, and I'm left wondering whether Johnny is meant as an aspect of Annie herself.
The second half of the album features two excellent songs that deal with the dodgy dynamics of her relationship with troubled actress Cara Delevigne, "Savior" and "Young lover", both dramatic, candid and ultimately touching pop songs. Annie's lyrics have always struck a particular emotional chord in me with her frequent mention of household appliances and everyday trivialities, like kitchen floors, bathtubs, carpets et cetera. Although you could jokingly start a "St. Vincent lyrics generator" soon just about slouching around different places in your apartment, they add to the intimacy of the slightly glossy songs.
"Fear the future", the angriest and heaviest song on the album, is really good, and together with "Young lover" (with its fantastic high note) really strengthens the back end of the tracklist. Unfortunately there are some slower songs towards the end that I don't care for quite as much as, say, "Seven crossed fingers", the closer on her self-titled album. But "Slow disco" is very pretty and has some absolutely lovely and very organic, expressive live strings, constrasting with the synthy feel to many of the other tracks.
All in all, MASSEDUCTION is rock solid and a triumph. St. Vincent is a fascinating artist through and through. A completely self-built female rock star, she's had to earn her status time and time again, her more eccentric facets being easily dismissed as pretentious and irrelevant. As if her back catalogue isn't already strong enough, MASSEDUCTION is St. Vincent proving for the umpteenth that the she is a stellar musician, and every eye turned her way is well deserved.
Best tracks: "Young lover", "Pills", "Hang with me", "Happy birthday, Johnny"
 |
| Yikes. It's garish as hell, but also eye-catching. |
A detour away from the album review:
I've seen St. Vincent live twice. The first time was when she warmed up for Grizzly Bear in Oslo in 2009. She was alone on stage with a Bernhoft-like setup: a couple guitars and a looper pedal. I hadn't heard of her before, but this would have been just after the release of her second album, Actor, the last before she officially became the most hyped indie artist in the world, and certainly the last tour where she was just the opening act. I was impresed and charmed, but not blown away, and the Grizzly Bear show is certainly what sticks today.The second time was in November last year. It was my last night in St. Louis, and my flatmate James came with me to the show. I still have confused sentiments about the show: Annie Clark was all alone on stage, wielding just her guitar, supported just by unseen instrumentals playing like karaoke tracks, for two hours. She stood in front of four curtains in various locations onstage, and I kept expecting some grand theatrical reveal, but it never came. The first half of the show was old (pre-MASSEDUCTION) material, and the second half was MASSEDUCTION played in full, from start to finish. During this section she was backed by some roof-height visuals playing behind her, showing grotesque, voyeuristic video clips such as ultra close-up, ultra slow-motion loops of Annie eating a slice of cake. Again, mixed emotions. But I think the most suprising aspect of it all was just how bare and stripped-down it was. MASSEDUCTION sounds rich and maximalistic, the kind of album that could have been performed with a full band and a crew of backing dancers. Instead it's just the instrumentals just as on the album; only St. Vincent's live vocal and guitar improvizations jacked up in the mix. I think the result can best be described as a very modernist, slightly absurd, quite provocative and immensely successful critique of pop culture.
 |
| St. Vincent dressed as a toilet at a 2016 show. |
Back to the album review:
The album opens with "Hang on me", whose deliberate restraint and touching intimacy immediately grabs my attention. It lures me in to St. Vincent's world and prepares me for whatever may come next, like the openers on the best albums from Perfume Genius ("I decline", "Otherside") or Susanne Sundfør ("Darlings", "Mantra"). And in all these cases, the tension built from the subtle opener makes the thrill of the banging second track ever so much stronger. "Pills" is an awesome pop song, not stopping after the infectious first three minutes, but morphing over to an epic, Pink Floyd-alluding coda.The streak continuous for three more very uptempo tracks cementing the album's aesthetic, all a perfect blend of sexy pop hooks and futuristic rock with lots of angry guitar work, gender-bending lyrics and some really awesome transitions. Then comes the quiet piano ballad "Happy birthday, Johnny", which again beckons us to come and sit extra close while Annie sings to whomever ("Johnny's just Johnny. Doesn't everyone know a Johnny?"). It's the third in a 'trilogy' of St. Vincent songs referencing Johnny, the previous of which was the stunning "Prince Johnny" off her self-titled album. It reaches an emotional climax when Johnny sings her own name back at her, and I'm left wondering whether Johnny is meant as an aspect of Annie herself.
The second half of the album features two excellent songs that deal with the dodgy dynamics of her relationship with troubled actress Cara Delevigne, "Savior" and "Young lover", both dramatic, candid and ultimately touching pop songs. Annie's lyrics have always struck a particular emotional chord in me with her frequent mention of household appliances and everyday trivialities, like kitchen floors, bathtubs, carpets et cetera. Although you could jokingly start a "St. Vincent lyrics generator" soon just about slouching around different places in your apartment, they add to the intimacy of the slightly glossy songs.
"Fear the future", the angriest and heaviest song on the album, is really good, and together with "Young lover" (with its fantastic high note) really strengthens the back end of the tracklist. Unfortunately there are some slower songs towards the end that I don't care for quite as much as, say, "Seven crossed fingers", the closer on her self-titled album. But "Slow disco" is very pretty and has some absolutely lovely and very organic, expressive live strings, constrasting with the synthy feel to many of the other tracks.
All in all, MASSEDUCTION is rock solid and a triumph. St. Vincent is a fascinating artist through and through. A completely self-built female rock star, she's had to earn her status time and time again, her more eccentric facets being easily dismissed as pretentious and irrelevant. As if her back catalogue isn't already strong enough, MASSEDUCTION is St. Vincent proving for the umpteenth that the she is a stellar musician, and every eye turned her way is well deserved.
Best tracks: "Young lover", "Pills", "Hang with me", "Happy birthday, Johnny"
